Log In

Home
    - Create Journal
    - Update
    - Download

LiveJournal
    - News
    - Paid Accounts
    - Contributors

Customize
    - Customize Journal
    - Create Style
    - Edit Style

Find Users
    - Random!
    - By Region
    - By Interest
    - Search

Edit ...
    - Personal Info &
      Settings
    - Your Friends
    - Old Entries
    - Your Pictures
    - Your Password

Developer Area

Need Help?
    - Lost Password?
    - Freq. Asked
      Questions
    - Support Area



Cleolinda Jones ([info]cleolinda) wrote in [info]fandom_wank,
@ 2008-09-08 13:25:00


Previous Entry  Add to memories!  Tell a Friend!  Next Entry
Entry tags:entitlement, fandom: harry potter, jkr doesn't know harry potter like i do, lawyerism, persecution, plagiarism, someone is wrong on the internet!, suck it up and deal, this is the wank that never ends

Lexicongate is over... for certain values of "over"
Breaking: Judge rules for Rowling in 'Lexicon' book case.


Note: My understanding is that SVA will not be appealing anything, because SVA is not the one named in the suit. RDR is. No word as to what he'll do.

(Watch That Page for ETAs.)

ETA: From [info]dorothy1901: WSJ posts a PDF of Judge Patterson's ruling.

From [info]faithwood: More articles, and the revelation that JKR/WB won $6,750 in damages.

ETA 2: JKR Statement Regarding Trial Ruling.

Via [info]wieimmer: Epic ONTD post is epic.

Commentary and reactions: NYTSmart Bitches; Galley Cat; Dear Author.

ETA 3: Via [info]diane_duane: RDR's statement.

foresthouse on LJ breaks down the ruling; Tom Spurgeon: "Generation Entitlement"; The Best Week Ever weighs in.

Current URLs for the Lexicon.

More Actual Lawyer commentary; Gothamist takes SVA's side.

ETA 4: Stanford Law: "Finally, remember that avada kedavra -- the killing curse -- is not always fatal. One wizard survived it. Three times. And it was he who cast the spell (and won't be named here) that ultimately suffered for it. Maybe someday the Lexicon will be known as The Book That Lived."

The Lexicon updates; Steve Vander Ark talks about the Verdict; Rowling Bitch-Slaps Potter Fans; Lee Goldberg chimes in (with now-deleted reference to the OTW).

Via rattlesnakeroot: Bluestocking: The Verdict in the WB/JKR Case is In and It's Confusing; J. K. Rowling and the Petty Victory; Ars Technica: Judge Waves Gavel - Says Avada Kedavra to Harry Potter Lexicon; TechDirt: Terrible Ruling: Judge Halts Publication of the HP Lexicon.

THUS SPAKE NORA ROBERTS.

One of Wired's blogs weighs in.

Gawker: J.K. Rowling Prevails Over Superdumb Harry Potter Encyclopedia.

Discussion at the Straight Dope boards.

ETA 5: Prof. Derek Bambauer at Info/Law discusses the case; praetorianguard goes over the case as well; "Beware of Bad Internships" by a former RDR intern ("So a man I regularly sold milk to and the publisher I was interning with were being sued by the creator of Hogwarts. Amazing and weird, but what took away from this drama's charm was the fact that I was still beating my laptop over my head wondering how to make Muskegon sexy").

ETA 6: Mark le Fanu at the Guardian weighs in; aaaaand here's Slashdot.

ETA 7: JKR's agents want to see SVA's new book, with bonus comment wank at Mugglenet (OH GOD NO PLEASE DON'T BE INFRINGING I CAN'T GO THROUGH THIS AGAIN); Dear Author comment wank, with bonus Nora Roberts; NPR's audio coverage; clearly, Diane Duane is using the Leaky Lounge lawsuit thread for her own nefarious purposes.

ETA 8: And the appeals begin. Also of note: "Rapoport said the legal tangle has boosted business for his company."



(Read comments) - (Post a new comment)


[info]mariem_1
2008-09-15 03:47 am UTC (link)
Here is the Mugglenet report: http://mugglenet.com/app/news/show/1867 and there is already wank in comments:

Posted by ScarecrowAust
He should just pack up and go home. Find another way to make money!

Posted by ScarecrowAust
HA I hope it gets taken off him... that would be awesome.

Posted by ginmo
lol at the finding Hogwarts thing I bet JKR is like "....O.O...." I guess there's a fine line between just plain CRAZY and HP obsessed.

Posted by kmg_photo
Yeah...this guy's a douche bag. He should just come up with his own material.

Posted by tinuviel786
I'm so sick of everyone hating on Steve. He's actually a really great person and he just made one mistake. I had the priviledge of meeting him at Prophecy 2007 and I went to every single one of his seminars because he knows soooo much about Harry Potter. Besides this whole book mishap, which I'm sure he did with the best of intentions, he is probably the ultamite fan. One of his seminars was on this new book that he wants to publish and it's going to be awesome because he has travelled all over England and Scotland finding the places that could be the actual settings from the HP series. He even found what could actually be Hogwarts! Which I think is so cool. I can't wait to read it!

Posted by marycatex3
LOL omg that picture. what a dork. dnw ...buuuuuuuuuuut , me being on a website about harry potter and the movies/theme park/naked horse raping elijah wood look a likes doesn't say much for me either. rofl

Posted by shewhomustnotbenamed113
-sighs- just leave this poor guy alone. he's been through enough already without you jerks

Posted by tinuviel786
I was just surfing the internet and I found this article http://blogs.timesunion.c om/harrypotter/?cat=27 o n the "feud" that this has cause in the fandom...well at least on leaky. Honestly I can't believe what has become of some of this fandom. Basically this article is about "Steve" supporters and how on leaky it's apparently a "you are with us or you are against" us mentality. Basically what I got out of this article is that a steve suppoter's comments were edited on a leaky comment page because it did not reflect the views of the majority. This person rebuttled on her own blog and is now being threatened by leaky who are saying they will take legal action because the person in question is saying that leaky moderators are unfair. I cannot believe that it has come to this, honestly the people at leaky are such bullies. I am definately not going to read Melissa's book.

Posted by JustGwenhwyfar
@kmg_photo: HE'S a db? What about all the Harry Potter fans insulting him? Any of you guys notice how much of a hypocrite Rowling is being about the whole thing? "I love this site, and it's an incredible resource, but now that you're trying to make money off of it I think you're a horrible, horrible person who has sapped my will to write!"

Posted by laetri
He is fifty-years-old and spends his life searching for the places in Harry Potter. Somehow, I question whether being "the ultimate fan" is something he should be striving for. Shouldn't be have a... life?

Posted by JustGwenhwyfar
I think he has far more of a life than the idiots spending so much time insulting him. Being passionate about something shouldn't be a crime, nor should it be worthy of flames.

Posted by frannylovesharry
tinuviel786 - I can't wait to read it either! I was there too and he made me cry with his passion and childlike imagination. Anyhow, most people who hate on Steve haven't met him and are saying what they are expected to say. It's easy to jump on the "Jo is right at all costs" bandwagon. Also, I don't think they have the right to read his book before it is published - if he lets them do so, it would be as a courtesy. They cannot be world censors of all things HP.

Posted by JustGwenhwyfar
I hope she cracks down on doujinshi next. People profit from that, and it hurts her far worse than what would probably have been an excellent guide to what she's created! jhh7487 is right -- she probably got all worked up over this because the Lexicon book would have been far better than whatever half-assed encyclopedia she could come up with.

(Reply to this)


(Read comments) -

 
   
Privacy Policy - COPPA
Legal Disclaimer - Site Map