It should be said that one of the main sources of fanboy rage in cases like this is that Uncharted is a PS3 exclusive. Platform partisans take reviews of platform exclusives way more seriously than multiplat games. It's sort of understandable why they feel that way but also hilariously wanky. I remember a recent thread on NeoGAF complaining that Giant Bomb was SO OBVIOUSLY biased against Sony because they only reviewed and Quick Looked Resistance 3 but didn't talk about it on their podcast.