11:33am: The Ones Who Wank Away From Omelas
Here's an ancient wank that's come back to haunt the board it was posted on.
Almost a year ago,
a thread was posted on the
Comic Book Rumbles forum asking a hypothetical question about Ursula LeGuin's short story,
The Ones Who Walk Away From Omelas. People weigh in their opinions, discuss what they'd do if they found themselves in the eponymous Omelas, and a thought-provoking discussion is had by all. Supposedly.
( Read more... )Even with several dissenting opinions, the debate remains fairly civil and philosophical, even with the entry into the discussion of Chuckg, veteran poster renowned for his abrasiveness and lack of tact. This state of affairs lasts only until the entry into the thread of the poster known as Sam.
( Read more... )Some people think that there are flaws in Sam's arguments. They aren't shy about
pointing them out.
A note: from observations of past threads in this forum, long since deleted when the board crashed, unfortunately, Sam appears to have a rather...jaundiced view of humanity. The posters aren't shy about bringing that up, either.
Then wank explodes when The Real Nemo announces, "
Sorry, the sheer amount of self-righteousness in this thread is making me sick..." And civility--especially from Chuckg--goes out the window. A few pages on, the debate between Chuckg and Sam starts to grow even
more heated, climaxing in
this magnificent tirade by Chuckg against Sam.
It's fortunate that good sense wins out and both Chuckg
and Sam leave the thread before anything
really bad breaks out, isn't it?
Unfortunately, this is just the prelude.
On the 16th of this month,
Metaphysician starts a thread asking which of the great philosophical debates to come up on Comic Book Rumbles should never be mentioned again. Omelas, obviously is one of them.
And wank explodes.