: Epic burn
Previously on The Hundred Years' Wank: RDR demands to see JKR's notes, judge lols; RDR files its response; the NYT weighs in; grudgepuppet accuses TLC's Melissa of tax fraud, recipes ensue.
Leaky grudgewank hits the Times Union. Key sentence: "Fansites such as The Leaky Cauldron and Mugglenet have been selling ad space on their sites for years and some have cried fowl."* Includes wank in the comments.
* Which fowl? "TURKEY! PHEASANT! CHICKENNNN!"
And then: JKR/WB Respond in Lexicon Suit. From TLC: "This is the last filing before a hearing on March 13 to determine if a preliminary injunction will be granted. After that there still may or may not be a trial to determine if infringement has taken place." ( Key points )
Whew. *goes to have a lie-down*
ETA: From
karintheswede, "Methuen, the British firm set to publish the Lexicon if RDR/SVA win, is ' "fairly confident" the court will rule in RDR's favour,' according to The Bookseller."
ETA 2 from TLC: "Harvard Law Wayne State University faculty and copyright/IP professor Derek Bambauer says that a recent NYT article on the case "Foul[ed] Up Fair Use" and contains an "embarassingly simple mistake of copyright law."
ETA 3: The filings are finally up at Justia.
ETA 4: Most viewed new story on Yahoo News: Rowling bashes 'Harry Potter Lexicon.'
ETA 5: RDR Books speaks. ( Read more... )
ETA 5b: The Lexicon story hits Smart Bitches, Trashy Books.
ETA 5c: From
ravenbell: an article from Cinematical: "Discuss: When Fans Go Too Far." Includes wank in the comments; I'm not really sure what's going on with the "bright shiny snowflake" comment.
ETA 6: Nora Roberts speaks:
NORA ROBERTS HAS SPOKEN.
Previously on The Hundred Years' Wank: RDR demands to see JKR's notes, judge lols; RDR files its response; the NYT weighs in; grudgepuppet accuses TLC's Melissa of tax fraud, recipes ensue.
Leaky grudgewank hits the Times Union. Key sentence: "Fansites such as The Leaky Cauldron and Mugglenet have been selling ad space on their sites for years and some have cried fowl."* Includes wank in the comments.
* Which fowl? "TURKEY! PHEASANT! CHICKENNNN!"
And then: JKR/WB Respond in Lexicon Suit. From TLC: "This is the last filing before a hearing on March 13 to determine if a preliminary injunction will be granted. After that there still may or may not be a trial to determine if infringement has taken place." ( Key points )
Whew. *goes to have a lie-down*
ETA: From
ETA 2 from TLC: "
ETA 3: The filings are finally up at Justia.
ETA 4: Most viewed new story on Yahoo News: Rowling bashes 'Harry Potter Lexicon.'
ETA 5: RDR Books speaks. ( Read more... )
ETA 5b: The Lexicon story hits Smart Bitches, Trashy Books.
ETA 5c: From
ETA 6: Nora Roberts speaks:
Fan fiction doesn’t copy the author’s story and call it their own, but uses it or the characters, as a springboard for another story. And not for profit. Much different, to my mind, than what Edwards did over many years and with many sources.
But this suit seems to involve someone who IS taking the author’s words, without her permission, and trying to sell it for profit. I’d sue, too.
I don’t mind fan fiction (understand those authors who do), but when I find my work on the internet--for profit or not--copied and claimed by someone else, I shut it down.
NORA ROBERTS HAS SPOKEN.