Mock. Mockmockmock. Mockity-mock-mock

History

15th March 2008

5:55pm: It's not plagiarism, it's *homage*!
Over on LJ, [info]caras_galadhon posts about a case of plagiarism in LoTRips fandom and why isn't anyone saying anything? Turns out not only did the author -- one [info]namarie120 plagiarize Jane Eyre for LotRips fandom, she also published it professionally.

In response, [info]koulagirl666 makes some interesting statements, including "The plagiarism standards in fandom are obviously markedly lower than IRL, else none of the movie-based fics or book-based fics would exist."

[info]caras_galadhon rebuts her argument, [info]koolagirl666 insists that no, no, it's differently, really! And that people have approached [info]namarie120 privately, so no one should say anything. (Never mind that the private approaches didn't work). [info]readgeekeasy rushes into ask so why are you being sooo MEEEEEEEEEEAAAAAAANNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNN????????!1111


And finally, [info]belle_lestrange wants us to leave great writers alone

ETA: More about this on [info]telesilla's LJ post.

ETA 2.1 : [info]namarie120 has deleted flocked posts on her LJ.

ETA 3: She'll never write again and it's ALL YOUR FAULT!

ETA 4: Caveat emptor.
Powered by JournalFen