On the planet you come from, this may be discussion, I admit. On my planet, it's wank.
Pointed to me by my roommate:

So, some girl post to BRPS saying that "Harry Potter journal based roleplaying = bad rping"

A lot of people disagree, saying "If that's your preference, cool, but it's not BAD." People make good and bad points on both sides.

She says everyone's wrong. Snarkily. Particularly when they have good points. And when people get snarky back, she whines about being "flame baited."

She demands logical explainations and when given them complains that it's not enough (Because, you know, everything make perfect, logical sense in Harry Potter, and nothing is excused as "magic") because Wizards have no REAL reason to keep and develop journals. Like most of us do?

And appear to have a sock puppet named tabari_avaren, or maybe just some one who follows her around being her yes person. I'm not sure.

I think raisplace summarizes everything nicely.

Edit: Sorry about the HTML.