Who wins at batshit?
I think there's batshit going on all over the place here. Yeah, the op shouldn't really breed her dog, and yeah, she does freak out like a machine designed especially to freak out, but that first post you refer to... it was not someone politely pointing out the many reasons why the OP should reconsider, it was a disguised link to a picture of dead puppies. roamingtigress should work for PETA.

It also appears that she may have actually sent the OP a text message to make sure she checked back on her post and noticed how much she'd been pwned. If this is the case, it does go some way to explaining why softest_fire went quite so crazy - it's one thing having someone reply to your LJ post, quite another to have them text you on your personal phone because they want to make internet drama.

Having successfully revived this post that had died so long ago those pups could have graduated college already, roamingtigress then went rushing over to dot_pet_snark to tootle her own horn over the drama she'd just started. Most of the other people on the thread are also members of DPS, who couldn't resist rushing over and joining in. Behold, manufactured drama! Admittedly, snarking drama you've been the primary cause of is an oft-recurring theme in dot_pet_snark but this does not, IMHO, make it any cleverer.

So, in conclusion, I would say so far it's a tie.