Yes i would blame the jew if she just left her friend cause he/she was/is a part of the Hitleryouth!
Once there was a fan called RedPassion who liked to draw her Mary Sue Emily with Louis XVI. Later she moved to HP fandom and started drawing Emily with Snape. Recently she made a comic about Snape, Emily Sue and Lily and it was full of sexism and stupidity. Here are some comments from RedPassion herself and the people who liked her comic:

“By the way I don’t think Lily was an egoistic person. Naive, yes. Incomplete character, yes. Boring, totally yes. BTW she is just a character I think poorly of .”

“She always used him for help at school our before to get details about the wizard world and most of all to married potter without to give a thought what could happened to Severus”

“I mean, how can Snape forsake his housemates and Dark magic when HE IS SURROUNDED BY THEM ALMOST 24/7?!”

“I’m sick and tired of all the fanart where Lily ‘forgives’ Severus. It should be the other way ‘round.”

“Some people are blinded by her protection of Harry and can’t find a fault in her”

“Lily can also be read as a gold-digger. By this view she would have been delighted to hear Severus say that one forbidden word. Here was just the excuse she needed to move up in the world.”

“The best thing that resulted out of Lily was the complexity of Snape because of all the heartache. If I were Lily, I wouldn’t have deserted my best friend just because he called me a name. After all, friends forgive each other, right?”

“He deserves way better than some childhood sweetheart who ditched him because he said one word. (Emily is making me sssooooo jealous, though XD) I am so tired of seeing SnapexLily fanart. She’s dead, and he’s on the market.”

“Lily was a bitch *nodnod* Running off with the people who tormented her best friend. Such a fickle woman -.-“

Also look at this gem of a conversation:

ladysugarquill

Well, Lily and Snape didn't fight because of one nickname. They fought because Lily got fed up Snape was into the Dark Arts and wanted to be a Death Eater (that is, people who think it's fun to torture and murder others because they're muggleborn - just like Lily). She spent 5 years trying to convince him not to become a MURDERER, but he was so scared of not belonging that he wouldn't listen.

And he didn't slip, he threw a racist insult to her face. Would you blame a jew girl for not staying friends with a member of the Hitler Youth? Knowing that he, or his friends, could kill her and her family tomorrow, just because she dared to be born from certain people?

RedPassion

I hold it like ~DoomOverlord. I won´t discuss this further, cause i would just repeat myself again and again. And i don´t think we both would chance or opinions on it. :/

I just can say that i´m half german and half british and i that don´t care of that when my friends needs me. No matter in what. Most of all when such a sad and bad background happened in their life like Snape has! Cause in that case it was Lily who felt ashamed for Severus infront of her friends even if actually Severus had "much more reasons" for it when we look at this from the point of e.g the different houses... Its true that you shouldn´t care from where someone came ect. And yes i would blame the jew if she just left her friend cause he/she was/is a part of the Hitleryouth! As said i´m am german and i was growing up in germany and not everybody there back in days where a Nazi!! Was Bad or something like that. E.g Sophie Scholl from the resistance movement the white rose "Weisse Rose" was there and she was pleased with it cause she could spend time with others girls in her age and she lost her life later cause she was executed cause she fought together with her brother and his friends against Hilter and for the jews and a free Germany! But even she was in the Hitleryouth she never was against jews! Hans Scholl also was in the Hitleryouth as well and he gave e.g his iron ration and cigarettes to a jewish girl even it was forbidden and he already worn his uniform and was a soldier of Hitler in that way... and he also would never have killed a jew!

(Post a new comment)

	janegraddell 2011-04-21 02:20 pm UTC (link)
	back in days where a Nazi!! Was Bad or something like that I really have no coherent response to this. (Reply to this)

	dottiness 2011-04-21 02:26 pm UTC (link)
	That last comment. What in the hell is even going on with it. (Reply to this)

	spawn_of_kong 2011-04-21 02:28 pm UTC (link)
	As said i´m am german and i was growing up in germany and not everybody there back in days where a Nazi!! Was Bad or something like that. Methinks someone has a poor grasp of history. Either that, or we really are dealing with someone who is 70-odd years old. (Reply to this)(Thread)

	indis_earfalas 2011-04-21 02:45 pm UTC (link)
	I'll go with a poor grasp of history + a nice bit of victim blaming and a massive dose of "Saint Sevvy is NEVER IN THE WRONG OMG!!!". Tangently, I've got all sorts of family that were on several sides of the war ... and some of the shit they told me, well, someone's wearing Sevvy tinted glasses. (Reply to this)(Parent)

chikane
2011-04-21 05:15 pm UTC (link)

Well, the statement that back then not everybody was a Nazi/a Nazi supporter is actually accurate.
It even goes for the Hitler Youth, because after a certain point, it became mandatory to join it - one'd only escape with backing from someone higher up in one's family. Being in the Hitler Youth did not mean on was necessarily for the Nazis. I know that many people today do not understand this, but historically, it really is accurate.

That said, the argument abou this misses the point, either way, because a jewish girl would have every right in the world to dump the ass of anyone who supported the Nazis. Only a complete douchebag would deny this.