7/28/09 10:06 pm
I think it was io9.com that told me that Warehouse 13 was steampunk. Unfortunately, it is.
It's unfortunate because for some reason in my head "government agency" and "gaslight fantasy" don't quite mesh in my head, so I'll be watching contentedly and then we'll be back at the warehouse and its infamous steampunk keyboard (nevermind the fact that I am already sick of the hacker subplot). It just seems like such a wasted opportunity to do dieselpunk.
The weird government agency- indeed, the government agency, is in America a hallmark of the twentieth century, and most people believe the twentieth century to have started between 1914 and 1918. This puts us out of range for steam, I'm afraid, unless the argument was that steam worked so well we never moved past it.
The supernatural- great for steam. Works fine for steam. But the BPRD is pretty much on the diesel side, coming together during WWII (unless I am mistaken, not being as well versed in the comic canon as I am the movieverse) and they haven't run out of work. And the show is definitely working with Clarke's third law, running around and finding artifacts that sometimes work in a sciencey way with supernatural effects. I wonder if the technology being so advanced that it approaches magic works better with the Dr. Frankenstein mad science club or the Dr. Strangelove one.
The tech- you just can't tell me that while Kevin Costner was out in the wild dancing with wolves there was a little house on the prairie starting to fill up with tickity-tockity junk. Because that's what the tech says. We came up with this stuff way back when and never bothered to change (or didn't have enough money). Why do they have the Farnsworth, then? And why is it woodish and brassy? The workstation- the flatscreen monitor with the typewriter keyboard- developed around the same time as the Farnsworth, or WWIIish, or earlier? The aesthetic of the tech confuses the hell out of me. Was the warehouse 5 years ahead of the steampunk trend and able to work it into their budget?
We have a secret government agency, which, as far as I can tell, developed in the 20th century. We have secret advanced technology, some of it which, as far as I can tell, was developed in the 20th century. We have the supernatural element, which, as far as I can tell, wasn't exactly a federal concern until the 20th century. So it's steampunk because...it's pretty.
Or, we have a group of early twentieth century inventors getting caught up in patent nightmares, nobody believes it can possibly logically WORK that way or something and their prototypes wind up in a basement somewhere. One of the alphabet soup offices formed during the depression gets to take care of the basement. We start worrying about the Nazi occult and decide to try out some of this weird stuff, hey, it works. Cold War days have little national need for ghost hunters, so this department gets to sit around and dust. Once in a while they get called in to consult on a national situation. Usually they don't have anything for the job; when they do, nobody is allowed to know about it. Department starts getting sent out after bigfoot and chupacabras, move west to deal with situations, slowly dying off. The last time they got any money was in the 70s for the move; before that, in the 40s during the war. You make do with what you have until it dies; when it dies you figure out how to fix it. So there's a secret government agency out in South Dakota hunting down strange tech, running off of machines that are at least 30 years old. You know if they find something useful it's getting patched in, right? That's what happens with my computer, and it's only 4 years old. So the whole place is full of wrenches and cables and CRTs and occasionally something from Mars or better. (I know the seventies are technically out of bounds, being a part of the atomic age, but so long as the tech itself isn't running off nuclear power I think it should count. But I have a fondness for wrenches and cables and CRTs so I am biased.)
Why isn't Warehouse 13 more like this? Maybe it's been done before; I do not know, for I am only an egg. I'm still watching it, obviously, but the more I think about it, the more that keyboard makes me angry, and start to think of ways it could still work without the tickity-tockity.