EQ2
I got back on EQ2 recently (yes, I can't bring myself to cancel even if I haven't played in months) to check and see the new SOGA models.

EQ2, may I ask WTF?

One of the fun things about fantasy games is the fanciful armor. EQ2 has bland armor. You say it's because you wanted to go for the realistic look. Okay, I'm cool with that. Realistic. Then why things like gravity-defying hair? And, why does every armor set you show outside of the game look like this?

EQ2, you lose.

There, I have whined. Now I can call myself a full-fledged (former) EQ2 player.