I am surprised because
We know how this works already, right? If you're a politician, you say whatever the fucking hell will get you elected. You noticed how McCain staffers thought Palin shat rainbows until the election was over, right?
THAT'S BECAUSE THEY LIED. I'm not saying Obama is a bad person (relatively, as we are talking about people who deceive, inveigle, and obfuscate for a living), I'm saying it was his job to lie. Something he did great! Now it's his job to actually Do Things, which is actually not going that great, but that's a different story altogether.
I mean, I know Jon Stewart was talking about how flowers and bunnies appeared whenever Obama was near, but IT WAS A JOKE. He's shown quite clearly that while he might, might care about gays, the environment, and so on, he either (a)doesn't have the ability or (b)doesn't care enough to get shit done. Maybe a combination of the two. I'm sure it's hard to get special snowflake Democrats to do anything, but I'm also sure that if Don't Ask, Don't Tell was that damn important to him, he would have killed it off by now.
I also don't understand what people are talking about when they gush about what a great speaker he is or how charismatic he is. I'm not just seein' it, dood. From what I do hear of him speaking, he doesn't really have a sense of timing and his speech doesn't sound very natural. In fact, I can completely understand why he had so much trouble convincing people that death panels didn't exist (although I still don't understand why they'd think death panels existed IN THE FIRST PLACE). I dunno, maybe his prepared speeches work better.
I guess he's got to have something, though, because people love him for no good reason that I can think of.